Access to knowledge in a world of uncertainty and politicisation
This article is part of the IES’s 2024 policy work on the theme of ‘knowledge’, addressing what evidence-informed policy means in practice and what it means for how environmental policy engagement is approached. This thematic work covers questions from the practical to the theoretical, from professional case studies and best practice to reflections on what forms of knowledge should be considered evidence in environmental policy.
In modern life, information is increasingly contentious. Technological and political developments have driven increased social distrust and made it harder to verify information. The increased prevalence of social media has changed the way that most people consume news, creating a world where misinformation travels as quickly and easily as facts.
For environmental issues, there are also challenges around politicisation. Inherently subjective questions about how we can create a sustainable future have carved out significant political divides, which have prompted increased uncertainty and introduced new barriers to the free passage of information.
As scientists, this presents a critical challenge: how do we promote access to knowledge in a world where politicisation, misinformation, and uncertainty run rife?
Why does access to knowledge matter?
What we know about the world around us is critical to how we can shape it as environmental scientists. Evidence on climate change has made a significant difference to our ability to grapple with environmental challenges. Similarly, understanding the way that policy decisions can affect people, the economy, and the environment is fundamental to finding effective solutions.
Importantly, in both instances it is not enough for that knowledge to exist in isolation, it also needs to be accessible to the right people at the right time. Environmental scientists have had an understanding of changing climate conditions for decades, but effective communication of that evidence has been essential to eliciting a wider response. Key examples, such as the climate stripes produced by the University of Reading, have widely spread knowledge about climate and the environment.
This knowledge is essential to supporting informed decision making, so we benefit significantly from as many people as possible being able to access knowledge. People and communities may not always act on knowledge, and they may not always choose the most environmentally progressive or sustainable choices, yet having knowledge is necessary to make genuinely informed choices, increasing the chance that we collectively get the outcomes we desire.
What does complexity and uncertainty mean for access to knowledge?
The quantity and availability of evidence has drastically increased over recent decades, encouraging evidence-led approaches to policy making and the widespread proliferation of knowledge. At the same time, resources and capacity have become increasingly limited, so the sheer vastness of information available has become harder to navigate, causing some people to feel that they have lost their agency to make decisions.
As the totality of evidence has expanded, complexity has also grown, often leading to increased uncertainty. Increased complexity has also made it necessary to distinguish between what policy makers need to know and what the level of detail that the public needs. Where the focus of evidence provision has shifted away from educating society towards a more direct relationship with decision makers, science has become somewhat estranged from the public.
Likewise, where scientific evidence has presented policy makers with difficult decisions, the provision of evidence has become more contentious, leading to the alienation of science from policy.
How can politicisation put access to knowledge at risk?
As populism has increased its role in global politics over the last 10 years, evidence has become a more controversial aspect of policy, making it increasingly politicised between different groups, some of whom embrace it, while others see it as a lower priority.
Major flashpoints, like climate change and the COVID-19 pandemic, have increased global reliance on scientific evidence and resulted in unprecedented visibility of scientists. In some cases, this has normalised science and its role in decision making, but it has also polarised opinions on science for those who disagreed with policy decisions made on the basis of that evidence.
While the outcome of the COVID-19 pandemic for life sciences has been an overall trend towards increased trust of science and evidence, environmental issues are still subject to polarisation.
Where scientific evidence is seen as pointing to specific policy choices, those who disagree with the choices are more likely to see the evidence itself as subjective. As there are inevitable subjective questions about the best approach to reaching a sustainable society, this raises serious concerns about excluding groups or compromising the ability to reach a consensus on addressing environmental challenges as misinformation becomes more common.
It also increases the prospect of uncertainty. Disagreements about whether evidence is legitimate make it harder to know who can be trusted, creating anxiety and making difficult decisions even more intractable to resolve. This can exacerbate indecision in the political sphere, creating a feedback loop which errs against action to resolve urgent environmental challenges.
How can environmental science promote access to knowledge?
Despite the risks associated with increased politicisation of environmental issues, there are also significant opportunities. The increased attention that comes alongside politicisation offers opportunities for engagement, as long as environmental scientists are prepared for the challenge of overcoming politically sensitive discussions and communicating the evidence.
There are also opportunities to reimagine the role of science in policy and public engagement, finding ways for environmental science to empower, rather than disempower, participatory decision making. Many of those working in the sector have already adapted to these challenges by:
- Developing networks and knowledge communities to promote efficient and effective engagement with the public and decision makers, rather than seeking to compete for limited public attention,
- Supporting the spread of scientific literacies, such as Carbon Literacy and systems literacy to empower the public to identify their own solutions, and
- Using best practice science communication techniques to cut through noise and engage the public with evidence more directly.
Despite positive progress, there is still more that needs to be done to make these approaches uniform, and to ensure that environmental scientists are given the skills they need to handle the ethical and practical challenges associated with bridging the accessibility gap between evidence and the public.
What next?
In 2023, the IES published its vision for the future of environmental science: ‘Transforming the Planet’. That vision sets out a pathway to give environmental scientists the skills they need to deal with challenges facing the sector, including the increasing politicisation of scientific evidence and environmental challenges.
The vision outlines a pathway to a future where environmental scientists are knowledgeable, skilled, diverse, and trusted, and where they help people to solve environmental challenges and co-create a sustainable society where people and nature thrive.
- Read 'Transforming the planet' for more information on the future of environmental science
- Learn more about our member communities and how you can get involved
- Read our 2023 piece on science, activism, and how to maintain an ethical approach as an environmental scientist
- Support the work of the IES by becoming an Affiliate, or if you’re a professional in the environmental sector working with science, join the IES as a member
Access to knowledge remains critically important, especially as our response to environmental challenges becomes ever more urgent. As such, the role of environmental science will be to provide that evidence and effectively communicate it in ways which are accessible and depoliticised.
Header image credit: © William87 | AdobeStock